原文:http://www.xtremesystems.org/for ... B-1866MHz-C9-Review
这货相信大家应该不陌生了,海盗船复仇者(Vengeance)DDR3-1866,标称9-10-9-27 1866 1.5v,ver5.11 hynix颗粒。型号为:CMZ8GX3M2A1866C9 。
最开始的时候,1600的复仇者用的是Hynix颗粒,也就是和上图一样的Ver5.11,后来换成了2.12,尔必达E颗粒,超频能力大幅下降。让这个产品线彻底沦为普条一流,价格也大幅下跌。今天要说的是1866的,从XS的文章来看,这个用户拿到的1866复仇者version变成了8.16,从海盗船给的version资料可以知道是南亚颗粒。通过测试他发现不好超,于是换了一套,结果还是一样的情况,因此可以断定ver8.16不好超。
以下是他的测试:
平台:
Asrock Z68 Extreme4 w\ UEFI 1.6
i5 2500K @ Stock
Corsair Vengeance 8GB @ 9-10-9-27 1N (XMP)
MSI Cyclone GTX460 1GB
640GB WD Caviar Black
800W Corsair HX
Win 7 Ultimate 64bit w\ SP1
超频结果:
9-9-9-25-1N @ 1866 1.5v Boots, unstable
9-9-9-25-1N @ 1866 1.6v, Boots, unstable
8-9-8-25-1N @ 1866 1.5v FAIL
8-9-8-25-1N @ 1866 1.56v FAIL
8-9-8-25-1N @ 1866 1.6V FAIL
9-9-9-25-1N @ 2133 1.6v FAIL
10-10-10-25-1N @ 2133 1.6v FAIL
11-11-11-25-1N @ 2133 1.6v FAIL
8-9-8-25-2N @ 1866 1.56v FAIL
8-9-8-25-2N @ 1866 1.6v FAIL
8-10-8-28-2N @ 1866 1.6v FAIL
8-9-8-28-2N-7-8-8 @ 1866 1.6v FAIL
里边本身hynix颗粒能跑的设置我已经标红,可是南亚根本就跑不了,接下来再看他的进一步描述:
As most of you know, I've worked very closely with Asrock ironing the bugs out of their P67 and Z68 boards, this included testing multiple configurations in which I used Mushkin, Patriot, no-name and G.Skill memory, all of which operated flawlessly. In this case, the problem is extremely cheap ICs or at the very least ICs which would suit a 1600MHz kit being used on a 1866MHz kit where to put it bluntly the ICs come across simply as sub-standard. While I don't dispute some Vengeance kits will be good, that is going to be because they use much better ICs and that will be reflected by the revision number on the modules. The kit I tested is revision 8.16 as I already mentioned, and they certainly do not meet any of Corsairs claims.
大概意思就是,他尽可能排除了主板bug影响的因素,并且他以同样的平台和设置测试过了博帝、mushkin、芝奇这些内存,都很顺利。最后他得出的结论是这组复仇者换了更廉价的颗粒,或者是本来应该用在1600套装的颗粒却被用在了1866上,导致这组内存基本没有超频能力。虽然一些复仇者系列是不错的,但这一组8.16却很差。
I've just got the replacement Vengeance kit and this replacement kit is absolutely atrocious. Once again I tried 9-9-9-25 1N timings @ 1866 1.65v and the system just BSODs at the login screen. I can't even get into Windows like I could with the previous kit. Lower voltages just result in the system failing to POST, period. I also didn't get a Rev. 5.11 kit, just another Rev. 8.16 kit. To be honest, I'm getting tired of being sent sub-standard memory.
但是还有更严重的,他换了一套还是v8.16南亚颗粒,而且结果体质还更差,本来那一套 1866 9-9-9 1.65V可以坚持到windows登录界面然后蓝屏,新换的这组连系统都进不了,降低电压甚至点不亮。
--------------
看来海盗船手上剩下的HY颗粒真不多了,但是最近我又得到消息,说海盗船将要特挑一些HY颗粒做成2133 8GB套装红梳子,而且售价不菲(具体我就不透露了,跟当年的hyper颗粒v2.1不会差太多),难道海盗船把这些HY颗粒全拿去挑,剩下的1866和1600就只能用垃圾颗粒来代替,完全不给任何超频空间了? |